Brütal Legend vs Guitar Hero 5 vs Band Hero

[angellinus]

Ive been thinking for almost a week on what is best. Maybe these forum may answer me?

Anyway whatever answer they gave me all of this games ROCK!

[rulerface5]

well it depends on what you like
i personaly like brutal legend because that is a action game

brutal legend- nothing like guitar hero. this is killing people with the power of music you dont play the music.

guitar hero 5- play the songs. alot of songs plus DLC. mostly metal or rock.

band hero-play songs, so far not many DLCs, alot of lighter stuff like evanescence and taylor swift and finger eleven

i hope this helps

[RedShadow]

Band Hero = Most horrible and boring setlist created.
Guitar Hero 5 = They had some good songs, some good bands, but it's horribly boring. It's not worth the money
Brutal Legend = Haven't tried it, still, looks good and I'm pretty sure it's better than those other two options.

[Lysdestic]

Apples or Oranges?

[RedShadow]

Apples or Oranges?

Oranges dude! What's wrong with you?!
:P

[vedicardi]

why would anyone compare these 3 games, or expect to come to some logical conclusion through the comparison of them?

[RealCheese]

why would anyone compare these 3 games, or expect to come to some logical conclusion through the comparison of them?

I'll agree with vedi here... But I will definitely go with Brutal Legend as the best game of the three. I haven't played the game or read anything about it, but all of Neversoft's Hero games have been terrible.

[jfosheezy]

all of Neversoft's Hero games have been terrible.

exept gh3
that one was good

[RealCheese]

all of Neversoft's Hero games have been terrible.

exept gh3
that one was good

That was the one that they put in 3-note chords to make songs more difficult. Definitely not what I call good.

[jfosheezy]

they had three note chords in gh2

[aduro]

gh3 was the worst by far

I don't understand how anyone could play GHWT and think that it was a worse game than GH3. I mean it's not good, but it's better in almost every way than GH3

[RealCheese]

they had three note chords in gh2

Only when they were necessary! Neversoft added them everywhere JUST to make the song harder.

[omfgdrphl]

Apples or Oranges?

This seems more like apples or coffee mugs.

[jfosheezy]

they had three note chords in gh2

Only when they were necessary! Neversoft added them everywhere JUST to make the song harder.

ehh good point

[felixdaman18]

It's really embarrassing to Neversoft/Activision that a rhythm game forum thinks that a non-rhythm game is better than 2 of their rhythm games combined.