Ghm or Ghvh? which has better graphics

[aduro]

Guitar Hero 5 -> Seems to like GH3 graphics (I mean the fretboard and the notes)

And yeah, the world tour engine was there until GH-SH.

GHVH also uses the GHWT engine

[amak11]

Wow aduro, you seem to think you are the resident genius on anything guitar hero related. I know im not, I just play the games for **** and giggles.i dont play for **** and giggles

I seem to own GHWT, GHSH, and GH5. I also agree mostly with what Death_au said.

GHWT engine to me is a slighty modified GH3 engine or a GH5 beta engine. GHM is a fixed GHWT engine with added features. GHSH engine is a slightly bigger step forward. It still uses a lot of the elements form the orginal GHWT engine, but it has a lot of enhancements. I would call it GH5 RC engine. GH5 engine was a complete overhaul from the WT engine. While GHVH uses a mixture of the the GHSH and GHM engines. Using RB2 for example, It is just a modified RB1 engine, while TBRB is its own game made from scratch.

Whoa.... wait a minute are we comparing the visuals using the engines as reference... omg how nieve of us. in the visuals department, GH5, GHVH, and GHM are equal. while GHWT and GHSH are equal.

[aander91]

I'm not sure if GHM is the same as VH and 5, but it's damn close, especially with the film grain effect. The character models are WT though.

[vedicardi]

GHM had WT's engine with a front hitwindow while GHSH had GHMs with a hitwindow extension. VH is probably a variation of GH5s engine. Graphically, GHM is GHWT with some slight fixing, while VH looks like GH5 with some sprucing as well. So I'd say VH, but after that I'd ask you why this thread even exists.

it's highly unlikely that something developed at the same time as, but separately from GH5, would be using it's engine. I'm pretty sure the development for GH:VH would have been started around when GH:WT was just finished at the earliest. I believe the unofficial reveal of GH:VH's production was around the time that GH:M was revealed to be in production, which was way before GH5 was announced.

It just seems very unlikely that they were working with an engine that was still in development.

---- EDIT ----

Wow aduro, you seem to think you are the resident genius on anything guitar hero related. I know im not, I just play the games for **** and giggles.i dont play for **** and giggles

I seem to own GHWT, GHSH, and GH5. I also agree mostly with what Death_au said.

GHWT engine to me is a slighty modified GH3 engine or a GH5 beta engine. GHM is a fixed GHWT engine with added features. GHSH engine is a slightly bigger step forward. It still uses a lot of the elements form the orginal GHWT engine, but it has a lot of enhancements. I would call it GH5 RC engine. GH5 engine was a complete overhaul from the WT engine. While GHVH uses a mixture of the the GHSH and GHM engines. Using RB2 for example, It is just a modified RB1 engine, while TBRB is its own game made from scratch.

Whoa.... wait a minute are we comparing the visuals using the engines as reference... omg how nieve of us. in the visuals department, GH5, GHVH, and GHM are equal. while GHWT and GHSH are equal.

GH5 looks way better than GHM

[death_au]

I also agree mostly with what Death_au said.

[snip]

...in the visuals department, GH5, GHVH, and GHM are equal. while GHWT and GHSH are equal.

That's not what I said

in the visuals department GHWT, GHSH, GHM and GHSVH are equal. GH5 is equal to none (until Band Hero comes out)
WTF Console are you playing on?
EDIT: I just reread and found you aren't playing GHM or GHVH. Check screenshots. You'll see they look the same.

[Rapt0r]

holy ****. By faceplaming once, I facepalmed 50 times. I win.

[aander91]

it's highly unlikely that something developed at the same time as, but separately from GH5, would be using it's engine. I'm pretty sure the development for GH:VH would have been started around when GH:WT was just finished at the earliest. I believe the unofficial reveal of GH:VH's production was around the time that GH:M was revealed to be in production, which was way before GH5 was announced.

It just seems very unlikely that they were working with an engine that was still in development.

Ahh, good point there. Here I figured that around the time of announcing it they started working on it. Usually the quality of the games reflect that it was thrown together in a matter of weeks so I guess it would make sense even if I was wrong. But seeing I still have yet to play VH I can't be a proper judge of it's hitwindow yet.

[slashfan7964]

personally, i dont care, as they seem to get better as the games go on, but idk whatever they are doing doesnt really matter as long as we get good graphics

[Stefan_Alfons]

personally, i dont care, as they seem to get better as the games go on, but idk whatever they are doing doesnt really matter as long as we get good graphics

Do the graphics really matter? I mean, the only people who will care about people are the people that always only care about graphics and so play on easy, and the vocalists. And they usually don't care THAT much. So the developers should rather concentrate on getting a better setlist and charting, but leave the graphics as they are.

[slashfan7964]

i dont care myself to muc dude, i just wanted other peoples opinions

[crushedsoul1298]

thats to everyone who thought ghm and ghvh arent the exact same engine.

[Kool Beans]

Metallica, but its cool how all songs in vh have specific motion capture